Best Daycares in New Albany, IN — 2026 Rankings

We ranked 19 daycares and childcare centers in New Albany based on licensing, accreditation, parent reviews, and childcare quality.

Top Daycares in New Albany

  1. #1 — New Albany Montessori School Score: 86%

    New Albany Montessori School is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, private school, school. Website: http://newalbanymontessori.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Private school, School. View full profile →

  2. #2 — JCC New Albany Pre School Score: 86%

    JCC New Albany Pre School is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: http://www.columbusjcc.org.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  3. #3 — Trinity Learning Ministry Score: 86%

    Trinity Learning Ministry is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: http://www.trinitylearningministry.org/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  4. #4 — Kids Care Academy Score: 86%

    Kids Care Academy is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool. Website: http://www.kidscareacademyindiana.com.

    Programs: Preschool. View full profile →

  5. #5 — Learning to Flourish Score: 86%

    Learning to Flourish is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, home service. Website: http://learning2flourish.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service. View full profile →

  6. #6 — Grace Lutheran Preschool Score: 80%

    Grace Lutheran Preschool is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, elementary school, school. Website: https://gracelutheran.school/.

    Programs: Preschool, Elementary school, School. View full profile →

  7. #7 — New Albany Early Learning Center Score: 80%

    New Albany Early Learning Center is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, elementary school, school. Website: https://www.napls.us/Domain/471.

    Programs: Preschool, Elementary school, School. View full profile →

  8. #8 — AcademyOne Childcare & Preschool Score: 77%

    AcademyOne Childcare & Preschool is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: https://www.preschoolnewalbanyoh.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  9. #9 — Outreach Christian Preschool Score: 74%

    Outreach Christian Preschool is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: https://newalbanyumc.com/preschool/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  10. #10 — Ready Set Grow Score: 69%

    Ready Set Grow is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, day care preschool, home service. Website: https://www.rsgrow.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Day care preschool, Home service. View full profile →

  11. #11 — Children's Academy Early Learning Score: 69%

    Children's Academy Early Learning is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, elementary school, school. Website: http://www.nafcs.k12.in.us.

    Programs: Preschool, Elementary school, School. View full profile →

  12. #12 — Floyd County Head Start School Score: 69%

    Floyd County Head Start School is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: http://www.fchsbirth2five.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  13. #13 — The Schoolhouse of New Albany Score: 69%

    The Schoolhouse of New Albany is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, home service, day care preschool. Website: https://www.signupgenius.com/go/10C0B49A5AB23A7F8CF8-62539146-busrsvp#/.

    Programs: Preschool, Home service, Day care preschool. View full profile →

  14. #14 — New Albany KinderCare Score: 66%

    New Albany KinderCare is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, child care and day care, school, education. Website: http://www.kindercare.com/our-centers/new-albany/oh/000556/?cid=LOC_Bing_Places_556.

    Programs: Preschool, Child care and day care, School, Education. View full profile →

  15. #15 — The New Albany Academy Score: 60%

    The New Albany Academy is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, child care and day care, school, education. Website: http://www.preschoolacademynewalbanyoh.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, Child care and day care, School, Education. View full profile →

  16. #16 — Floyd County Head Start Birth-to-Five Score: 57%

    Floyd County Head Start Birth-to-Five is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, school, education. Website: https://www.fchsbirth2five.com/.

    Programs: Preschool, School, Education. View full profile →

  17. #17 — Adventure Time Academy Score: 49%

    Adventure Time Academy is a childcare center in New Albany, IN. Programs include Preschool, day care preschool, home service.

    Programs: Preschool, Day care preschool, Home service. View full profile →

  18. #18 — Tutor Time Score: 37%

    Tutor Time is a childcare center in New Albany, OH. Programs include Preschool, child care and day care, school, education.

    Programs: Preschool, Child care and day care, School, Education. View full profile →

  19. #19 — La Petite Academy Score: 29%

    Programs: Preschool. View full profile →

How We Rank Daycares & Childcare Centers

Our Guide Score percentage combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and contact presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), accreditation such as NAEYC (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of operation (2%), then normalizes across captured positive categories. Read our full methodology →

Frequently asked questions

Who is the #1 daycare in New Albany?
New Albany Montessori School is currently the #1 ranked daycare in New Albany based on our Guide Score, which evaluates parent reviews, licensing status, accreditation, and quality signals. See the full ranked list above.
How are daycares ranked in New Albany?
Our Guide Score percentage combines weighted evidence from Google rating, review volume, web and contact presence, profile completeness, accreditation, press recognition, and years of operation, then normalizes across categories with captured positive evidence. There is no paid placement.
How much does daycare cost in New Albany?
Childcare costs in New Albany vary by program type and age group. Full-time infant care commonly ranges from $800–$2,500/month; preschool programs run $600–$1,800/month. Each center's profile page lists contact information for current rates.